« Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute -- Platforms & Usability Info Sharing | Main | The Technology of the HBS Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness and Microeconomics of Competitiveness course »

May 25, 2006

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Looks like a really interesting session! At Baker Library we're looking into allowing users to submit websites to our search engine and tag them with keywords.

Note: This week there was a social tagging workshop held in Edinburgh. A number of interesting papers from the workshop are available at:

http://www.rawsugar.com/www2006/taggingworkshopschedule.html

Correction on Adam Seldow's title -- he's the founder of Gradeweb, Inc. (http://www.gradeweb.com)

My notes from today's chat:

Social tagging
* user-defined meaning for content
* helps organize, store info
* social aspect -- connect with other researchers

Relies on and helps create a "folksonomy" -- from Wikipedia: A "folksonomy" is a collaboratively generated, open-ended labeling system that enables Internet users to categorize content such as Web pages, online photographs, and Web links. The freely chosen labels – called tags – help to improve search engine's effectiveness because content is categorized using a familiar, accessible, and shared vocabulary. The labeling process is called tagging. Two widely cited examples of websites using folksonomic tagging are Flickr and del.icio.us.

Info is accessed in several ways -- by related tags, users, related users, etc. Social tagging increases the amount of info available to you.

toptaggers.com - allows you to weight tags by certain users heavier than others

Social tagging allows you to:
* discover new materials by leveraging the search success of others
* associate your topic to other topics through related tags
* harness & categorize "gray literature"
* rate, comment, and add your 2 cents
* create niche groups within sites

Controversy:
* 'incorrect' tags
* spagging (spam tagging)
* opportunity cost of neglecting off-line resources
* licenses and restricted access to materials
* unsafe/inappropriate links
* obscure docs -- harder to locate?

Bottom line -- works well as a *supplemental* research tool.

TOOLS
* Del.icio.us -- bookmark sharing via tags (bought by Yahoo)
* Flickr -- tagging photos (bought by Yahoo)
* Penn Tags
* Unalog (Yale uses this)
* Connotea
* TeacherShare.org (based on open-source Scuttle platform)

Social tagging sites:
http://3spots.blogspot.com/2006/01/all-social-that-can-bookmark.html

Common features:
* bookmarklets add URLs quickly/easily
* you and others can tag the same bookmark (build meaning)
* export/import bookmarks to and from browsers
* user profiles -- pub/private reading lists
* popular/recent tag clouds
* RSS feeds in several standard formats

Advanced features
* export bookmarks to bibliographic software (EndNote, etc)
* OpenURL, XBEL (SML Bookmark Exchange Language), XOBIS (Organic Bibliographic Info Schema), and MODS (metadata object description schema) support
* Form pub/private groups
* commenting, post to blog, email to friends, ratings on-the-fly (AJAX)
* User rankings for 'trusted' users
* personal tag cloud generators
* custom RSS feeds by tag, user, or group

"Library 2.0" -- making your library's space (virtual and physical) more interactive, collaborative, and driven by community needs. Get people into / back into library by making it more relevant.
* build a collaborative community on/offline
* not that different from what happens now *inside* physical libraries
* social tagging networks personalize the search process with colloquial language
* social tagging only a small piece of library 2.0 virtual communities

Social tagging in libraries
Pros
* search using own language
* related article and user recommendations
* organize and discover 'gray literature'
* connect with people sharing interests
Cons
* loss of a controlled vocabulary, taxonomies, ontologies
* content often not peer-reviewed
* site licenses may restrict usage
* complacency with other peoples' reading lists

Adam's favorite social bookmarking sites:
* Connotea
* TeacherShare.org (Adam's pilot using Scuttle open source software)
* Del.icio.us

Adam does not normally begin his research with social bookmarking sites, but it is a great supplemental set of sources. He sometimes enters his search phrases in a social tagging site to see what related tags/users appear.

Adam then played a 10-minute Flash presentation/overview of how he uses the tools in research.

How can social tagging tools help educators connect with researchers?
* share "usable knowledge"
* prof development
* student/prof reading lists
* interest groups

Teacher 2 Teacher
Teacher 2 Student
Student 2 Student

* Tagging integrated as a pat of a suite of tools or as part of school's existing portal

------------------------
DISCUSSION

Harvard Grad School of Ed's Gutman Library -- just starting to investigate this with Adam and determine context for usage. Starting to think about where it could be piloted -- an Ed school or FAS (undergrad) course. Penn system was sponsored by a fac member wanting students to share annotated bibliographies in a film class.

HBS Baker Library starting to investigate similar things like Search Space (used at MITRE) -- can add a URL to search results, etc. See social tagging as a useful adjunct. Most library folks in the room agreed -- it seemed to be a very useful adjunct and most librarians counsel their researchers already to use a mix of controlled vocab and jargon, etc, in their searches.

Adam sees this as a low-cost way to generate interest in libraries and make them more usable (tag clouds, etc).

How do you get folks to do *work* when researching -- adding metadata? Group discussed how primarily users do this for themselves, and sharing is a secondary perk.

Group discussed Harvard environment and how

Larry brough up usability -- Delicious is overwhelming and unusable. But sites are getting better. Alexis -- amazon feature showing screenshot of website next to link. Blinklist.com -- social bookmarking site that puts picture and user ratings, shows tags, etc.

onlywire -- bookmarklet to add to a bunch of sites.

http://seldow.com/HBS/

I just signed up for a Connotea account, and I have "implemented" FindIt@Harvard.

Basically, I filled in the appropriate openURL resolver URL, and it worked perfectly!

For people at Harvard who want to try it, here's the URL for Harvard's openURL resolver:

http://sfx.hul.harvard.edu/sfx_local

Naturally, I labeled it FindIt@Harvard.

Hal

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.